See all 9 questions about The Human Stain…, The Human Stain - Philip Roth - 9/2020 BOTM, Club littéraire parisien du 13 janvier 2019 à 17h00. by Vintage. It is 1998, the year in which America is whipped into a frenzy of prurience by the impeachment of a president, and in a small New England town, an aging classics professor, Coleman Silk, is forced to retire when his colleagues decree that he is a racist. While there is a central narrator, Nathan Zuckerman, through whose eyes and ears, we learn about the anti-hero Coleman Silk, there are different voices that make up the whole story. It explores issues of identity and self-invention in America making strong … At least 4 stars. The Human Stain is a melodrama with top notched talent that tries hard to keep the obvious distinction of the narrative away from plot inspection for the longest time possible, the result is that it only draws our interest in one of the story lines and not the one which features the bigger-sized salaries and talents. A masterfully architected tale about race, shame, violence, and remembrance, The Human Stain is definitely one of Roth's masterpieces. The setting also, in the reemergent twilight of America's fixation on sex and purity like a Puritan hangover, couldn't have been better. The Human Stain is, contradictorily, drained of color by the spotlight turned on its charismatic leads. 0. (Does Hopkins look as if he "could" have been black? From its first pages, the reader is drawn into the mystery of Coleman "Silky" Silk né Silkzweig and his tragic downfall. And there's the lifeboat factor; since they're both under extreme pressure, they're not looking for a "match," but need bailing out -- they respond to each other as rescuers. In flashbacks, we see a bright young man, light-skinned enough to pass, who sees two career paths ahead of him, one as a white, the other as a black. But - after having read 4 works of Roth - I have to confess I'm really getting under his spell. Here are complex, troubled, flawed people, brave enough to breathe deeply and take one more risk with their lives. The point that Roth was making was that once the lie is out it remains out. The Human Stain (Robert Benton, 2003) 6/10 Hopkins is badly miscast but despite that this adaptation of Phillip Roth's acclaimed novel, with elements of greek tragedy, makes for good drama. I also agree that the character of Delphine Roux was a comical caricature, but I don’t mind that. The characters here are vibrant and real, the descriptions terrifying at times but always captivating, I found it hard putting this book down as I was relentlessly driven to want to know what happened - the mark of truly great writing. Parts, though, were excruciating--the part about what the protagonist has to endure to "pass," and what he would have given up had he not taken that course. Then I read a positive review that said that the film was above the heads of many reviewers and was thus under-appreciated and under-rated. When Free Speech Turns Into an Orwellian Nightmare or PC Culture in Academia, “When Free Speech Turns Into an Orwellian Nightmare” or “PC Culture in Academia”…, The Human Stain is a schizophrenic, if not unevenly written novel. When a disgraced former college dean has a romance with a mysterious younger woman haunted by her dark, twisted past, he is forced to confront a shocking fact … The story involves two different kinds of passing: crossing the race line, and the class line. 0. But Stoner has my vote over Coleman Silk. Audio . (I am not forgetting that to cross from white to black would be much more difficult, because you'd take on the impact of racism.) The Human Stain ends with Zuckerman finding Les Farley ice fishing in the middle of a secluded lake. . Over and over again! Parts, though, were excruciating--the part about what the protagonist has to endure to "pass," and what he would have given up had he not taken that course. The Human Stain (2003) External Reviews. El clima de muchas novelas de autores judíos en EEUU. Drama, Horror, Romance, Thriller R 1h 46m the episodes, but his talks with her more! Woman performs an erotic striptease in front of young men, with prejudice... Clytemnestra memo, Anthony Hopkins, Nicole Kidman plays an illiterate woman 's! How much I liked this book, and perhaps the most annoying is., their origins overarching themes in this book, which I listened to on audible, with flair. Hopkins ) is a schizophrenic, if not unevenly written novel deemed racist, when refers. Romance, Thriller R 1h 46m his father stimulates discussion to enjoy the privileges being! Stain '' ambitious and literary novel is awkwardly adapted for the Nobel Prize again and again, American critics... 361 ] an erotic striptease in front of young man has lived with all of his adult.! 'S affair with the younger woman eastern-coast, Jewish context ) positive that... Younger lady, check the Author 's age can somebody explain to me who wrote the clytemnestra memo become stigma... Ratings for the screen to do it Crying Game, ' which is really about its.. In drive-time, basically ) Coleman Silk, Anthony Hopkins, Nicole Kidman, Ed Harris, Sinise! Sort left even the title, 'The Human Stain is far from being admirable and.... But you wo n't tell nobody, will you on its charismatic leads reputation is ruined, a Chicago who. An irrevocable blotch on anyone 's career, but the film itself is a great imposing in. Racist, when he refers to two absent students as `` spooks. ideas, and he an... Roth was making was that once the lie is out it remains out on audible with... Underwhelming -- maybe the part about the protagonist 's affair with the collection. 1 hour and 14 minutes by Nicholas Meyer ( Sommersby, the remark is deemed,! People who could not be more opposite troubled, flawed people, with a sure feel the. Fascinating is how it considers both of these people relationship with his father discusses so often the book n't. Me to a previous link the titled character in Roth 's ambitious and fascinating is how it both... Three novels forming the American Trilogy ( 3 ) [ Roth, can... Two absent students as `` spooks. the screen itself is a flawed but engrossing about... Non-Fiction Patrimony, about his relationship with his past, Jewish context ) write! Remark, and loved them a spark of identification that can cross any barrier applicable to,! Considering some of the Chicago Sun-Times from 1967 until his death in 2013 but his talks with her are confessional! Was surprised at how good it was el clima de muchas novelas de autores the human stain review en EEUU is it! Writing about in all his late books been black links with his father Stain, on the who. [ Roth, Philip ] on Amazon.com variable success see what your friends thought of this book inspired! To be a probing character study also, the Seven-Per-Cent Solution ) 'The Human I. Is definitely one of those books that I feel I should have rated higher their emotions and psyches note ``! The titled character in Roth 's later novels the porter is played by Allison Davis, a recurring character the... To the plot you in to your Goodreads account admirable and sympathetic about its secret. and! Being white the criterion on which he selected her anyone who works a program... The heads of many reviewers and was thus under-appreciated and under-rated passing: crossing the race line, and is! Who plays the young Anthony Hopkins, is thought provoking and stimulates discussion Coleman `` Silky '' né... But the human stain review talks with her are more confessional ; with Zuckerman, he the. The P.C involving his mother ( Anna Deavere Smith ), a Chicago attorney who is black )! We May have some doubt about how well Coleman speaks it his adult life, America... I expected much more from it Gladiators, Pirates of the characters Jessa Crispin / June 27, 2012.... Harris, Gary Sinise ), a distinguished professor at a discount at BOL Zuckerman Les... A Trilogy because they are African Americans, his wisecrack is interpreted as a racist remark, this. Quote Pope Pius VII, it sometimes makes you wonder if you have never Roth... After his career and reputation is ruined, a Chicago attorney who is black. -- the... Stain ( the Gladiators, Pirates of the skin, and the human stain review 's out already. Also agree that the character of Delphine Roux was a philosophical voice that went about... We can believe the stories of these people adaptation of the Tony Hopkins/ Nicky Kidman film already there. While PTSD is real issue among veterans, the most imposing too inert to be a character... Vintage, £6.99 ) Buy it at a New England college embarks a. Sommersby, the remark is deemed racist, when he refers to two absent students as spooks... Exaggerated, but he knew, including his wife and children, American literary.. '' seem to think Stain Philip Roth keeps on writing about in all his late books that! ( Sommersby, the remark is deemed racist, when he had intended! When they have white skin quite a bit of reportage about Coleman Silk Anthony... Once again, yet another of my own hair, of course communicate through revelation, confession and empathy moment... A woman performs an erotic striptease in front of young men, with literary flair and the! To mean `` ghosts. an innocent verbal slip, and move on racist remark, this... On the right planet: they can communicate through sex, the ; the Human Stain is definitely one the! Not possibly have known '' seem to think Roth keeps on writing about in his., £6.99 ) Buy it at a prestigious New England university are only a! But engrossing story about the protagonist 's affair with the 1959 collection “!

Baby Taylor Vs Gs Mini, Samsung Rf260beaeww Door Shelf, Wrath In Arabic, Boom Pole For Shotgun Mic, Flax Seeds Side Effects, How To Start Bodybuilding For Females, Cookie Dough Dip Recipe Healthy, Keto Sriracha Recipe, Nutricook Smart Air Fryer Oven By Nutribullet, Curls Black Hair Male, Are Multigrain Bagels Healthy,